Amish Chicken Thighs/Mushrooms/Green Beans Sautéed in Cast Iron Pan

I love cast iron pan cooking and am thrilled it is experiencing a true renaissance. I received several cast iron frying pans in 1970 for a wedding gift and have been cooking with them on and off ever since. There is something special about the way food tastes when cooked in these pans. And I know I am not ingesting any plastic coatings while using them.

Chickens musshroom in the pan USE

Home cooked food simmering in the pan on the stove top. YUM!

I added a Lodge cast iron dutch oven to my collection a few years ago and this had become my most used pan. I can cook anything in the deep bottom pan and I use the top as a griddle. I bought my two-piece set at Cracker Barrel and paid around $50.00. You can find out more about this company that works out of South Pittsburg, Tennessee by going to their website at It’s also fun to scout out old cast iron pans at sales and shops and bring them back to usable condition.

If you like the history of places and people the way I do you will find the history of the Lodge Company and foundry intriguing too. Find that here:

Our current favorite meal is Amish chicken thighs cooked in our deep cast iron pan. This is a recipe I have developed over the years through trial and error and I change it out depending on what fresh vegetables I have on hand in the fridge or growing in the garden.

Plated on white cutting board USE

Because we do not eat our own chickens (I can’t eat my pets!) I have been buying the Amish grown chickens in the grocery store. I vary between baking a whole chicken in the winter months, grilling chicken breasts or stove top simmering some tender dark meat thighs.

When I make the thighs on the stove top I start out by simmering onions, peppers, and fresh from the garden green snap beans. While those are simmering in the cast iron pan, I prepare the meat and make up some water and flour gravy. After the onions have turned translucent I lightly braised the meat. After the meat is lightly browned I add a small amount of organic chicken broth to keep the meat from sticking. Some days I add cut up carrots, grape tomatoes halves, zucchini slices or whatever vegetables I have on hand from the garden. I also added ground pepper, my home-grown dried and crushed basil, caraway seeds and a tiny sprinkle of pink mineral salt. This time I had some wonderful organic Portobello mushrooms buttons in the fridge so I added slices of them for the last 10-15 minutes of the cooking process.

Today I served this chicken dish with cooked potatoes (my husband loves his potatoes with butter!) and sliced and marinated fresh tomatoes. I passed on the potatoes and still I felt fully satisfied.

Amish chicken beand tomatoes potatoes

Chicken, beans and mushroom w/tomatoes and basil and potatoes with butter!

Enjoy this tasty meal on us!

Small House homesteader and amateur cook, Donna


Sautéed Amish Chicken Thighs with Mushrooms

  1. Brush on olive oil in cast iron pan.
  2. Add one small onions sliced into rings
  3. Add fresh sliced red peppers to taste
  4. Add one cup of fresh cut up green snap beans
  5. Cook the beans and onions until the onions are translucent.
  6. Add chicken thighs (fat cut off)
  7. Lightly sautee both sides of the thighs to brown them and seal in the juice
  8. Add fresh ground pepper, caraway seeds, crushed basil or any herbs of your choice.
  9. Feel free to add carrots, zucchini, summer squash or tomatoes if you like.
  10. Add 1/3 cup of chicken broth (or water) to keep chicken from sticking. Gently pry up chicken pieces as you turn them.
  11. Make up light gravy using water and flour and add to the pan.
  12. Continue to sauté for about 30 minutes or until both the chicken and vegetables are cooked through and tender.

Add the sliced mushrooms approximately 10 to 15 minutes before you plant to serve this dish.


One thought on “Amish Chicken Thighs/Mushrooms/Green Beans Sautéed in Cast Iron Pan

  1. Pingback: Amish Chicken Thighs/Mushrooms/Green Beans Sautéed in Cast Iron Pan | Small House Under a Big Sky

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s